Go Back
COMMENTARY: Why Andrew Marsh was named after being charged – and why Nick Sharpe never should have been article image from Spartans Illustrated

COMMENTARY: Why Andrew Marsh was named after being charged – and why Nick Sharpe never should have been

The media had a legitimate reason to identify Marsh; the eight months before (and the five weeks after) still need explaining

By David Harns

University of Michigan receiver Andrew Marsh was identified by news organizations Thursday after Pittsfield Township Police released information about an indecent exposure case involving a food delivery driver.

His name belongs in those stories because Marsh has been charged with a crime. Police investigated the allegation, the case went to the Washtenaw County Prosecutor’s Office, prosecutors authorized a misdemeanor complaint, and there is now a court proceeding attached to his name.

That is exactly where the line should have been drawn three months ago with Michigan State offensive lineman Nick Sharpe.

Unfortunately, it wasn’t.

The Detroit News - and only the Detroit News - identified Sharpe on Aug. 28 while police were still investigating a sexual assault allegation against him. He had not been arrested or charged, prosecutors had not reviewed the completed investigation, and police were still gathering evidence while working through two significantly different accounts of what happened.

Sharpe’s name was published anyway.

After an 11-week investigation, the Clinton County Prosecutor’s Office declined to charge him. Supplemental reports later showed that the woman told investigators during another interview that the sexual contact was consensual and that Sharpe had not used force or coercion.

By then, his name had already spent weeks attached to a sexual assault allegation.

That is why what happened Thursday with Marsh is worth looking at closely - because the process for Marsh was very different.

According to Pittsfield Township Police, a food delivery driver contacted the department Feb. 2 and reported an incident at a residence in the 5000 block of E. Spaniel Drive.

She said a male answered the door with a blanket over his shoulders and no clothes underneath it, then opened the blanket and exposed himself as she turned to leave. She also reported receiving a message from the customer afterward telling her she was attractive and asking her to return.

Police said officers contacted the resident, confirmed that he was the person who received the delivery, and identified him as the suspect.

They did not identify him publicly.

Even in Thursday’s release, more than nine months after the original complaint, Pittsfield Township described the suspect only as an 18-year-old male from Pittsfield Township.

What changed was the status of the case.

The Washtenaw County Prosecutor’s Office authorized a misdemeanor complaint of indecent exposure on Oct. 14. A notice for Marsh to appear in court was generated Nov. 18 and he is scheduled for arraignment and pretrial proceedings Dec. 2. Court records allowed reporters to connect Marsh to the otherwise unnamed suspect in the police release.

That is legitimate reporting.

Marsh has not been convicted of anything, and a criminal charge should never be written as proof that an allegation is true. He is entitled to contest the charge, and the case now moves through the court system.

But there is a case.

That was never true with Sharpe.

And while the Marsh case provides a good example of why waiting for a charge is usually the responsible approach, there is another part of this story that deserves attention.

We have no idea why it took this long.

The complaint was made Feb. 2. The prosecutor’s office authorized the charge Oct. 14. That is more than eight months.

And right now, the public record does not tell us where those eight months went.

Pittsfield Township’s release says a request for review of charges was submitted to the Washtenaw County Prosecutor’s Office. It does not say when.

If Pittsfield Township spent most of those eight months investigating the case and did not send it to prosecutors until September or October, that tells us one thing.

If the prosecutor’s office received the case in February, March, or April and did not authorize a complaint until October, that tells us something very different.

At this point, we do not know which happened.

We also do not know what police were doing during that period. The release does not say when officers contacted Marsh, whether investigators sought records from the food delivery company, whether they obtained the message the complainant said she received afterward, whether subpoenas or other digital records were involved, or whether there were delays obtaining evidence.

We do not know whether the case was actively being investigated throughout those eight months.

We do not know whether Pittsfield Township submitted it to prosecutors once or whether prosecutors sent it back for additional work.

Those are questions for Pittsfield Township Police, and the first one is simple: On what date was complaint No. 26-2325 submitted to the Washtenaw County Prosecutor’s Office?

The prosecutor’s office then has its own information to provide: When did it receive the case?

Until we have those two answers, blaming either police or prosecutors for the length of the investigation would be guessing.

There is another unexplained period after the charge was authorized.

The prosecutor’s office authorized the complaint Oct. 14, but the notice for Marsh to appear in court was not generated until Nov. 18. Pittsfield Township issued its media release the following day.

What happened during those five weeks?

When was the complaint actually filed with 14A District Court? When was Marsh notified? Why was the notice generated Nov. 18? Was the timing of the Nov. 19 police release connected to the court notice becoming public? Was the release issued because reporters had begun asking questions?

We don’t know.

The University of Michigan added another interesting piece Thursday when football spokesman Dave Ablauf said the program had “just been made aware” of the incident involving Marsh.

That creates another set of questions.

Did Michigan really have no knowledge of the case until Nov. 19, despite the complaint having been authorized Oct. 14? When did Marsh learn that he was being charged? Did anyone from police or the prosecutor’s office contact the university during the investigation? Was the university informed only after the court notice was generated?

Again, none of those questions should be answered by assumption.

They should be asked.

The Washtenaw County Prosecutor’s Office is currently headed by Eli Savit, who was elected Michigan attorney general earlier this month and plans to leave the prosecutor’s office Dec. 4 before taking over the Attorney General’s Office in January. Savit spent much of 2026 campaigning statewide while continuing to serve as Washtenaw County prosecutor.

That is relevant context, but it is not evidence that Savit personally handled Marsh’s case or that his campaign had anything to do with the timeline.

We do not even know yet which prosecutor reviewed the charging request.

That needs to be asked, too.

Who handled the case? When was it assigned? Did Savit personally have any involvement? Was additional investigation requested? How long did the charging review actually take?

Those answers will tell us far more than speculation will.

There is also no basis right now to claim that reporters knew about the Marsh investigation for eight months and deliberately kept his name out of the news.

Maybe nobody in the media knew.

We should not give news organizations credit for withholding something we cannot establish they had, any more than we should accuse them of covering something up without evidence.

What we can evaluate is what happened once Marsh’s name was published.

By that point, prosecutors had authorized a criminal complaint, a court proceeding existed, and reporters had a public court record connecting him to the case.

That is a fundamentally different journalistic decision from opening an investigative police report, finding the name of a person who has not been charged, and putting that name in a sexual assault headline.

The Society of Professional Journalists specifically warns journalists to consider the implications of identifying criminal suspects before they face legal charges. Its Code of Ethics also reminds journalists that having legal access to information does not automatically provide an ethical justification to publish everything in it.

Sharpe’s case is a pretty good example of why.

The News was legally entitled to obtain the police report.

That did not mean Sharpe’s name had to be published before investigators finished their work.

There can be exceptions. Police may need help locating additional victims or witnesses. Someone may present an ongoing public-safety concern. The subject of an investigation may be a public official whose conduct carries an extraordinary public interest.

None of those circumstances were apparent in Sharpe’s case.

There was an allegation, an active investigation, and a Michigan State football player whose name made the story considerably more clickable.

Then, weeks later, the investigation ended without charges.

Marsh’s situation reached a different point before his name became part of the story. Prosecutors made a charging decision, and the case entered the court system.

That is why his name should be reported. It is also why Sharpe’s never should have been published when it was.

For now, though, there is Marsh's story to finish reporting - by those on the UM beat.

Why did a complaint made in February not result in an authorized charge until October? When did police send the case to prosecutors? How long did prosecutors have it? Why did another five weeks pass before a notice to appear was generated? Why did Pittsfield Township release the information on Nov. 19? When did Michigan and Marsh learn about the charge, and who made the decisions along the way?

We don’t have those answers yet.