It started with a sarcastic reply to something I posted on X (Twitter) after Michigan State's 21-14 loss to Washington on Saturday.
"Thrilled to read your article about the player who lost us the game today! Thanks David!"
I thought through a lot of different ways to respond. I even started writing a reply, but the more I thought about it, the more I realized that what I wanted to say went quite a bit deeper than one football game, one player, or one frustrated fan on social media.
And it probably deserved more than a tweet.
My job – if you can call it that – is to tell the stories surrounding Michigan State Athletics. Sometimes those stories are fun, exciting, and incredibly easy to tell. A team makes a remarkable play, pulls off an upset, wins a championship, or accomplishes something nobody thought possible. Those are the stories everyone wants to read, and they're certainly fun to write.
But every one of those stories has another side. Somewhere, someone is sitting down to write about the team that lost. About the kid who dropped the pass, missed the tackle, threw the interception, or made the mistake that everyone will remember.
I think those stories deserve to be told, too.
In fact, I think there's something fundamentally wrong with a society that only wants to hear about people when they succeed. We're increasingly conditioned to celebrate winners, mock losers, and move on to the next thing without giving much thought to the human beings involved. Social media has made that incredibly easy. We can reduce somebody's entire existence to a mistake, fire off a clever insult, collect a few likes, and never think about that person again.
And that brings me back to Cam Fancher.
Fancher didn't wake up Saturday morning hoping to disappoint tens of thousands of Michigan State fans. He didn't spend the last several months practicing, studying film, lifting weights, and preparing for an opportunity because he wanted to fail. When he suffered an injury last month, he could have decided his season was over. Instead, he worked his way back onto the field.
Saturday, he was called upon when starting quarterback Alessio Milivojevic went down. Later, Fancher suffered another injury scare, briefly left the game, and returned to continue fighting alongside his teammates.
He threw a touchdown pass. He also threw an interception. There were plays he'd love to have back, and there were opportunities Michigan State failed to capitalize on.
He knew all of that.
And when the game ended, that young man sat down in front of reporters and television cameras and answered every question put before him.
He had just experienced a disappointing loss in front of his home crowd. He was physically hurting. He knew he'd made mistakes, and he knew there would be criticism.
He could have avoided the microphones. He could have let his coach speak for him or given a few meaningless answers and walked away.
Instead, he sat there and faced the questions.
He talked about the interception. He accepted responsibility for trying to make a throw that didn't work. He talked about fighting through his injury and what motivated him to return to the field.
He explained that he wanted to fight for his brothers, his teammates, his coaches, and Michigan State University.
I watched a young man handle an extraordinarily disappointing situation with more maturity and accountability than we sometimes see from people twice his age.
And I think that deserves some recognition.
There is something else about this that I wish more fans understood.
As reporters and writers and storytellers, we're given a window into these programs that most people will never have. I believe one of our most important responsibilities is to give fans a window into that window.
We sit in rooms with these players and coaches. We ask them questions. We listen to them explain their decisions, their mistakes, their motivations, and their disappointments. Sometimes we see them after the greatest moments of their lives. Other times, we see them when they'd probably rather be anywhere else.
That's a privilege, and I believe it comes with an obligation.
Our job is to accurately report what happens on the field. We also have an opportunity to help people understand the human beings behind what happens there.
Most fans will never sit across from Cam Fancher and hear him explain what it took to return from an injury. They won't be in the room when a player takes responsibility for a mistake or talks about what his teammates mean to him. They won't see the expressions on their faces or hear the emotion in their voices when they explain something that matters deeply to them.
We get to experience those moments.
And if we're doing our jobs well, we find a way to share them.
That doesn't mean becoming cheerleaders. It doesn't mean protecting athletes from legitimate criticism, ignoring poor performances, or pretending that losing is acceptable.
Quite the opposite. I think responsible coverage requires asking difficult questions, particularly when things aren't going well.
But there's a difference between holding someone accountable for his performance and treating that performance as the entirety of his worth.
Pat Fitzgerald went out of his way after Saturday's loss to explain how important players like Fancher are to what he's trying to build at Michigan State. He talked about the kind of people who will help restore the foundation of the program.
Are all the players on this roster as talented as Michigan State needs them to be to compete for championships? No. Is this program where it needs to be? Absolutely not. The record makes that obvious.
But there's something to be learned from the players who continue to show up, who put themselves in difficult situations, who know they're probably overmatched at times, and who keep competing anyway.
Last night, as I often do, I left the press box and sat in the stands for the final few minutes of the game.
I watched thousands of Spartan fans stay until the end, even as another loss became increasingly obvious. I watched people continue supporting a team that was about to lose another football game.
I think those fans recognized something about the effort they were watching. They understood that the young men walking off that field had given them what they had to give, even if it wasn't enough.
There's a certain maturity in being able to recognize that distinction.
And I worry that we're losing it.
We talk constantly about wanting young people to develop character, perseverance, accountability, loyalty, and resilience. We tell them that failure is part of life, that adversity builds character, and that the measure of a person is how they respond when things don't go their way.
Then we watch a young man experience those exact circumstances in front of thousands of people, and some of us decide the only thing worth saying about him is that he lost us a football game.
What exactly are we teaching our kids when we do that?
What are we telling them about their own inevitable failures? That their effort only deserves recognition if it produces a result we like? That people will support them as long as they're successful, but their struggles aren't worth understanding?
I've tried to teach my four sons, who are Spartan fans through and through, to look beyond the first layer of what they're watching. The scoreboard tells you who won. It doesn't tell you much about what happened to the people who played the game.
And sometimes the most interesting, meaningful, and worthwhile stories come from the people who didn't win.
My boys have played soccer their whole lives. I've watched them succeed, struggle, make mistakes, and experience the kind of disappointment you can't fix for them. Some of the moments I've been proudest of them had absolutely nothing to do with whether they won.
I hope they understand that the same is true of the people they watch on Saturdays.
I hope they can appreciate an extraordinary performance without worshipping the person who delivered it. I hope they can recognize a poor performance without humiliating the person responsible. And I hope they never become so invested in a team's success that they lose the ability to recognize the humanity of the people wearing its uniforms.
I also think it's worth examining how casually we assign blame in sports.
Football might be the ultimate team game. Eleven players have to execute on every snap. Coaches make decisions. Opportunities are created and wasted throughout four quarters. There are dozens of plays that contribute to the final score.
Yet we're perfectly comfortable pointing at one young man and declaring him responsible for everybody else's disappointment.
That's a pretty heavy burden to put on someone, especially from the comfort of our phones.
I'm not suggesting we hand out participation trophies, stop keeping score, or pretend a 21-14 loss is some kind of moral victory. Fans want better execution, better talent, better coaching, and better results.
But you can demand all those things and still recognize that the young men representing Michigan State deserve to be treated with some basic dignity.
Somewhere along the way, we've started acting as though being a passionate fan requires being relentlessly cruel when things don't go our way.
I don't understand that mentality.
The players on the other sideline have stories, too. Their families have watched them struggle, sacrifice, and grow. Their teammates know things about them that we'll never see. Sometimes they win. Sometimes they lose. Sometimes they make the play everyone remembers for the wrong reason.
They're still people worth understanding.
And I think the journalists, writers, and storytellers who are fortunate enough to have access to those people have a responsibility to help the public understand them.
I keep coming back to that press conference Saturday night.
Cam Fancher knew the questions were coming. He knew reporters weren't going to sit there and congratulate him for a great game. He knew he'd be asked about mistakes, missed opportunities, and another loss for the Spartans.
He answered anyway.
To me, that says something about his respect for the game, his teammates, the program, and the people who follow Michigan State football.
And when an athlete is willing to offer that kind of access and accountability, I believe it's worth our time to listen.
We ask young people to stand up and take responsibility when things go wrong. We should be willing to acknowledge it when they do.
So, yes, I wrote about Cam Fancher after Michigan State lost to Washington. And I would write that story again.
I would also write about the player who missed the game-winning shot, the goalie who surrendered the deciding goal, or the baseball player who struck out with the bases loaded.
Because the opportunities we have as reporters extend beyond documenting who won and who lost. We're given a chance to see people in moments that reveal something about their character, their struggles, and their lives.
I believe we owe our readers more than a collection of statistics, scores, and highlights. We owe them an honest account of what we see and hear, including the things they might otherwise never know.
And if the only stories we consider worth telling are the ones about people who win, I think we're going to miss an awful lot of what makes sports worth watching in the first place.
More importantly, we're going to miss an awful lot of what makes people worth knowing.



